How the penalty is calculated
Most banks charge a set amount of interest, at your CD's rate, on the amount you take out. For a $10,000 CD at 4.00% APY with a 6-month penalty, that's about $196. It doesn't matter how much interest you've earned; the penalty is the same on day 10 or day 700.
A typical schedule looks like this, but your bank's may differ:
| CD term | Typical penalty |
|---|---|
| 3 months or less | 1 month of interest |
| 4 to 12 months | 3 months |
| 13 to 36 months | 6 months |
| Over 36 months | 12 months or more |
Some banks use days (90, 180, 365) and some charge a share of the interest you would have earned over the whole term, which can be much larger. Check the "early withdrawal" section of your Truth in Savings disclosure; banks must give it to you before you open the CD.
Should you break a CD for a higher rate?
The default example is a $10,000 2-year CD at 4.00%, eight months in. You've earned $264.92. The 6-month penalty is $196.11, so you'd walk away with $10,068.81. Reinvesting that at 4.50% for the remaining 16 months gives $10,677. Keeping the CD gives $10,816.
So the new rate would need to be above 5.52% to win. The shorter the time left, the higher that bar gets, because there's less time to earn back the penalty. As a rule, breaking a CD for a rate bump of less than a point rarely pays.
When breaking a CD makes sense
- The alternative is high-interest debt. Paying off a 24% credit card beats any CD rate.
- Rates have jumped a lot and you have years left on a long CD.
- You need the cash and the other option is a loan.
If you'd only need part of it, ask whether the bank allows partial withdrawals. The penalty then applies only to the amount you take out. For future savings, a CD ladder keeps some money close to maturity.
Avoiding the penalty next time
Read the early withdrawal section before you open a CD; it's part of every certificate of deposit agreement. If you might need the money, a no-penalty CD or a CD ladder keeps it within reach. Any penalty you do pay is deductible; see taxes on CD interest.